I have empathy for book reviewers. Once word gets out that they review books, they’re inundated with authors pushing their books. (Hint to readers who want free books – become a book blogger. If you review it, they will come…).
In the process of submitting my books for review, I’ve visited a lot of book blogs. I don’t want to bother someone who isn’t interested—it’s a waste of my time and theirs. So I have suggestions to streamline the review process to eliminate inappropriate and/or unwanted requests.
- Post your review policy. Be specific about what you read and review. List the genres you like and the ones you wouldn’t touch with a 10-foot pole.
- Have a search box on your blog so that I can search by name or title to see if you’ve reviewed my book in the past. I try to remember to check back, but often reviews don’t post until months after I’ve submitted a request. When I remember to check back, I need to be able to search by my name or book title. I can also check to find out that you’ve never reviewed any of my books, so I can cross you off my list of contacts.
- Update your policies and statements periodically! I’ve visited a number of blogs stating they’re no longer accepting review requests until they’ve worked through the backlog. But I know from having visited several times the message is a year old. Or the blogs state in January they won’t accept reviews until March, and here it is August. So are you accepting requests or aren’t you?
- Include a list (with links) to past reviews organized by author name so I can see who you’ve reviewed in the past. This helps me to decide whether you will be interested in my book.
- Tell me how to submit a review request. Some blogs have no email address posted or online form. If you’re not accepting requests, you should say so. If you are accepting reviews, tell me how you want to be contacted.
- If you use a request form, don’t make the buy link mandatory. You say you need a long lead time to review a book, but I can’t submit it to you in advance of publication if you require a buy link because I won’t have it until release day.
- If I’ve submitted to you several times and you know that you will never, ever, even under threat of death, read or review my book, and you think, “Oh, god, not her again,” please email me and tell me. Then I’ll stop contacting you, and we’ll both be happier. I can’t tell you how many times I put a reviewer on my “last call” list and then had a book accepted for review. So, I’m pretty persistent. I’ve learned that “next time” often does pay off. You’re going to have to tell me outright if you don’t want to be contacted. A lack of a response won’t work on me. Not for a long time anyway.
- If you are a “consumer reviewer” and request my book from NetGalley, you should know that I check out your past reviews. Mainly I verify that you do review the books you request. If you state that you review on Goodreads and your “book blog,” and your reviews are two, three, four years old (or nonexistent), I’m going to decline your request. What you say in your bio on NetGalley matters too. Ifyou talk about books and how much you love to read a variety of genres, that’s a big plus. If you have no bio and no links to where you post reviews, I’m going to decline your request. If you say you’re so busy you rarely have time to read or review, why in the world would I give you my book?
If you’re author, what do you wish reviewers would do? If you’re a reviewer, what do you wish authors would do to make your job easier?
Did you enjoy this post? Please share it on Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest!